Does Baseball Care Who She Will Be?

Women In BaseballImage Source;

The First-woman-in-baseball, who will she be? The game of baseball doesn't care and by that I mean that the game itself doesn't care who she will be nor does it care who plays it.

On the contrary, the game of Baseball SCREAMS out for the best Athletics on the planet to come play. It imposes no restriction or pre-qualification's, it only requires the very best athletics.

Baseball has been labeled as America's Sport and it shares its very existence to the collaboration of both Men and Women.

But admit it or not baseball has always been viewed as a game played best by men and only now are, women in baseball, starting to truly challenge the status quo.

Inevitably, the question that sparks the most controversy is, Will there ever be a, woman, (MLB) professional baseball player?

Steven Goldman with SBNation describes the challenges awaiting that first-woman-in-baseball. His article "The Rotation; Will women ever play in the majors?" paints a grim picture of what it's going to take before we see the first woman break the gender barrier of Major League Baseball.


Let us not be confused, baseball is big business and it has been a business from the first day a field was roped off and people were charged admission to watch men play the game. The first woman in baseball will have to deal with the perceptions of men and their perceived place in the game.

The real challenge for the first women in baseball is in the Numbers.  I compare major league baseball to a double-decker party bus. Everyone on the bus wants his seat and will fight hard to keep it.

There are, currently, only 1200 seats (Based on 40 Man Roster) on that bus and only the very best can ride. Your ticket to ride is earned by how well you play the game.  That is a very select group of athletics capable of commanding a lifetimes worth of income in a short period of time (less than 15 years).

Therein lies the dilemma confronting woman in their fight to play in major league baseball. From an athletic perspective the first women in baseball will need to take their own spot on the bus.

But does a woman posse the necessary skills to take a seat on that bus? 

Lets Take A Look At some Facts

Baseball history in America goes back prior to the 1800s. In Pittsfield, Massachusetts, 1791, an ordinance existed that banned the playing of baseball within 80 yards of the towns meeting house.

The history of baseball in America spans our entire existence as a country. What has been hidden, deep in baseball history, is the presence and impact of the first women in baseball.

In fact, women could argue that they and not men actually introduce baseball to America.

In the early 15th century there was a game called "Stool-Ball". It was played on a square field that was tilted on its end (Sounds like our baseball diamond).

Initially played by "Milkmaids", this game predates Cricket, Rounder and Baseball. The presence of women in baseball history mirrors that of Men. A fact that should not catch anyone by surprise when you consider that Man and Woman predates games themselves.

The history of women in baseball already pocesses a rich and impressive body of work.  Although female teams were considered a novelty, by the early 1920s, there were several female players who were attracting attention at the amateur and semi-pro level and were considered talented enough to play for all-male teams

First women in baseball

lizzie arlington

Lizzie ArlingtonLizzie Arlington 1876

Content shared from ""

Arlington, Lizzie (b. 1876)

First woman to sign a contract in the baseball minor leagues (Atlantic League). Name variations: Stoud; Arlington was a professional name. Born Elizabeth Stride in Pennsylvania, in 1876.

Lizzie Arlington is regarded by many historians as the first female to play organized baseball in the 19th century. Ed Barrow, a future member of the Hall of Fame, claimed he brought her into professional baseball when he served as president for the Atlantic League. Details of her brief stint in professional ball remained virtually unknown until Al Kermisch, a baseball enthusiast and researcher, ferreted them out.


·       April 1, 1931, Virne Beatrice "Jackie" Mitchell Gilbert, one of the first women in baseball, strikes out both Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig in a Major League Baseball game at Eagles Stadium in Nashville, Tennessee. 

·        Effa Louise Manley (March 27, 1897 – April 16, 1981), co-owner of the Newark Eagles with her husband Abe Manley from 1935-1946. She was the first woman to be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

·        Mamie "Peanut" Johnson, Toni Stone and Connie Morgan were three of the first women in baseball to play minor league baseball when they signed with the Indianapolis Clowns of the Negro Leagues in 1953. Mamie was a pitcher with a strong right arm and a wicked curve ball. Mamie was never accused of throwing like a Girl.

Jackie Mitchell-1931

Jackie Mitchell

Played head to head against Men, recording strike out of Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig in 1931.

Mamie "Peanut" Johnson

Mamie "Peanut" Johnson

Mamie was the first woman in baseball to play against men professionals in the Negro Leagues back in 1943.

Effa Manley

Effa Manley

Effa Manley was co-owner of the Newark Eagles Baseball Franchise in the Negro Leagues-(1935 to 1946). Effa holds a special place in Baseball History as she was the first Woman in baseball to be inducted into Baseball's Hall of Fame.

Toni Stone

Toni Stone

Toni was the first contracted Female to play against Men in the Negro Leagues. She signed a contract with the Indianapolis Clowns in 1949 but she was a virtual outcast in the league as the men outwardly defied her presence. 

Julie Croteau


Julie was the first woman in baseball to play men's NCAA baseball. She was also one of two women to ever play in a MLB sanctioned winter league. Her baseball glove and picture is currently displayed in the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, NY. In 1988 Julie filed a lawsuit against her high school (Title 9) for her to play on the Varsity baseball team (She Lost).

Mo'ne Davis

Mo'ne Davis

Mo'ne reached Rock Star status in baseball with her appearance in the 2014 Little League World Series. Mo'ne, a pitcher, featured a fast ball that reached 73 mph at Little League distance (equivalent to 93 mph on a major league field).


Here is a snapshot of some of the hurdles that the first women in baseball will to meet 

on their quest for a Seat On The Bus.

Baseball's response was to modify the baseball field dimensions, it in an attempt to accommodate women. The thinking being it would level the field of competition. While well intended the modifications were only pacifiers for baseball's establishment (Men) and didn't address the burning question, "Can The First Women in Baseball Play against the Men in Professional Baseball"?  

Today, the highest skilled athletes playing the game of baseball are men. That is not because of the game of baseball but simply a case of opportunity to play.

Baseball is an extremely complex sport that requires the mastery of a very high level set of human skills.  To play the game at its highest level challenges the very best athletics on the planet.

It is my personal contention that baseball requires more skill than any of the other recognized Major Sports.

To master the game of baseball an athletic must be skilled in three basic areas.

1.        Catching

2.        Throwing

3.        Hitting

No other sport requires that same level of skill. Yes there is Golf and Cricket but only baseball requires a player to, counteract or overcome ball speed, in order to initiate play.

I have been scouring the internet searching for an algorithm that identifies statistical data showing that Men have the ability to react quicker that Women but as yet I have not found any.  

So what does that mean and what affect does it have on the first woman in baseball and her ability to play major league baseball? My answer to that question is Nothing, Baseball doesn't care.

The only thing that really matters is how well that first woman in baseball can play the game of baseball and how men adjust to the challenge of competing, head-to-head, with women for our baseball jobs.

Women In Baseball-The Answer!

My answer, to the controversial question of "Will Women Play Professional Baseball" is, ABSOLUTELY Yes. I will go even further and say that it is my assessment that she is already here.

That means she was born before 2016 and is here now, awaiting her place in history. I  challenge any of the Neigh Sayers,  to prove me wrong if you can.

Baseball is not a game of Size, Strength and Speed but rather one of Reaction, Quickness and Consistency. All skills that women are born and equipped with from birth so Baseball doesn't really care.

The first women in baseball will have quite the road to travel and the journey will add another chapter to the book of baseball.

So women, just remember, you heard it here first and I would love to hear your views.

What Is Your View On Women In Baseball?

Can Women Compete With Men In Major League Baseball?

Do you have a great story about the accomplishment of Women in Baseball? Share it!

[ ? ]

Upload 1-4 Pictures or Graphics (optional)[ ? ]


Click here to upload more images (optional)

Author Information (optional)

To receive credit as the author, enter your information below.

(first or full name)

(e.g., City, State, Country)

Submit Your Contribution

  •  submission guidelines.

(You can preview and edit on the next page)

Recent Articles

  1. Duncan Park in Spartanburg, South Carolina

    Jun 08, 20 03:07 PM

    Duncan Park is a wooden stadium still in use in Spartanburg, South Carolina. It is primarily used for baseball and is currently the home of the Spartanburg

    Read More

  2. American League Park, The Magic Behind The Name

    Jan 09, 19 01:34 AM

    American League Park was one of the first baseball stadiums built for Professional Baseball (Now the MLB).

    Read More

  3. Baseball Head Gear For Every Head

    Dec 14, 18 04:56 PM

    We've Got Baseball Head Gear For All of You Avid Baseball Fans.

    Read More

New! Comments

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.

Please note that all fields followed by an asterisk must be filled in.

Share this page:

What's this?

Enjoy this page? Please pay it forward. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it? var l = window.location.href, d = document; document.write('<form action="#"><div style="text-align:center"><textarea cols="50" rows="2" onclick=";" ><a href="'+l+'">'+d.title+'</a></textarea></div></form>');

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.